Welcome to Kinsey's Italian Cafe
At Kinsey's Italian Cafe, we celebrate the heart of Italian cuisine in the charming town of McCordsville, Indiana. Our story begins with a passionate commitment to authentic flavors and warm hospitality. From our housemade garlic knots to signature pasta dishes like Shrimp Alfredo and Kinsey's Meat Trio, each plate is crafted with care. Guests rave about our delectable appetizers, such as the unbeatable bruschetta and pepperoni breadsticks. The inviting atmosphere and attentive service create a truly memorable dining experience. Join us and savor the taste of Italy, where every meal tells a flavorful story and leaves you longing for more.
Kinsey's Italian Cafe: Reviews & Ratings
First visit but definitely not the last! Server was excellent and the food stellar. Got the lasagna, rav, spaghetti meatball sampler and loved every bite! Tons of leftovers for tomorrow and the Italian dressing might have been the best I've ever had!! 10/10!! Highly recommend!!
Loved this place! Food : 10/10 in terms of quantity, flavor Ordered Chicken Cattiatore with their house salad. Staff : Alexa my server was so warm and made me feel welcome.
This was our first time visiting this restaurant and will gladly say I was very impressed. I got Kinsey's Trio Cheese specialty pasta and added grilled shrimp. The garlic knots are housemade and taste very great. My husband was a fan of his pizza topped with grilled chicken and sausage. We were greeted as we walked in the door and as we walked out. Very nice Italian Restaurant.
The best Veal Parmesan I've found in Indiana! I'm always on the hunt for it and try it at every Italian restaurant. The service was outstanding as well.
Delicious food. Great staff! Good atmosphere! The bruschetta is the best I have ever tasted. The salad and beef ravioli were delicious! The house merlot very good. Great place to eat!!!!
What an excellent find! My mom and I went there for pizza and pasta, and I was impressed with the taste of everything (you have to try the addictive garlic knots). The pizza is especially good and I think I'll be going to them as often as I can for that.
First time dining here. Food and service was very good. My chicken cheesesteak sandwich was amazing. The fries was tasty also. You get a lot of food for your money. Our server Hailey was very attentive and quick. We will be back.
Loved the buffet! They have a salad bar with lots of toppings, 5 kinds of pizza, super tasty ziti, zucchini fries, fried fish, mini cinnamon and sugar donuts, potatoes with bacon and cheese, wings, and more. My son created his own calzone which was also good and huge!
Location
-
6383 W Broadway A-D, McCordsville, IN 46055, United States Hotline: +1 317-336-1300
Welcome to Kinsey's Italian Cafe, a charming gem nestled in the heart of McCordsville, Indiana. Located at 6383 W Broadway A-D, this delightful eatery invites you to indulge in the heartwarming flavors of authentic Italian cuisine reimagined with a modern twist. With a reputation for stellar service and mouthwatering dishes, Kinsey's stands out as a go-to destination for both locals and visitors alike.
The extensive menu offers an array of tempting options, starting with appetizers that are perfect for sharing. Guests rave about the Cheesy Garlic Bread, Spicy Cheese Curds, and Garlic Knots—housemade delights that set the tone for a memorable meal. The Chicken Tenders and Pepperoni Breadsticks are other crowd favorites, ensuring that there's something for every palate.
For those seeking a heartier fare, Kinsey's truly shines with its pasta dinners. Patrons have highly praised dishes like Beef Ravioli and Fettuccine Alfredo for their rich flavors and generous portions. Signature dishes such as Chicken Bruschetta and Shrimp Alfredo showcase the restaurant's commitment to freshness and culinary excellence. With options like the Cajun Shrimp Alfredo and Chicken Cattitori, there's a delightful fusion of traditional and contemporary flavors that simply begs to be savored.
- Customer Favorite: The Kinsey's Trio Cheese specialty pasta with grilled shrimp has captivated diners, with its creamy, rich profile promising to satisfy even the most discerning of taste buds.
- Perfect for Families: Leftovers are a common delight, as many customers appreciate the generous servings—ideal for a hearty meal to go.
- Unforgettable Service: From the moment you walk through the door, the staff at Kinsey's ensures you feel welcomed and valued, contributing to an overall pleasant dining experience.
Customers like Cheri Griffin and Linda Hanks have shared glowing reviews, highlighting the deliciousness of dishes such as lasagna and the unique Italian dressing. AJ Travis even claims to have found the best Veal Parmesan in Indiana here, a testament to the restaurant's commitment to serving exceptional Italian fare. With each plate, Kinsey's Italian Cafe crafts an experience that goes beyond just a meal; it's about tradition, quality, and an unwavering dedication to delighting patrons.
If you find yourself in the McCordsville area, don’t miss the chance to visit Kinsey's Italian Cafe. Whether you're in the mood for a cozy family dinner or a special night out, this restaurant promises an extraordinary Italian experience that will leave you craving more.